I remembered quite a few online buying clubs in Germany around 2002-2005. Some electronics, some clothing labels, some early china gadgets. They had problems finding matches between products and buyers in the long term. Most customers wanted quicker delivery and the small bargain could not compensate. Your cat food example would work better, because of the steady supply demand. Some of the clubs I mentioned ended up in crowdfunding platforms.
chaos.social – a Fediverse instance for & by the Chaos community